Most frozen salmon that turns out mushy was thawed wrong, not frozen wrong. Wild king holds up well in the freezer. Thaw it slowly and cold, dry it off, and it cooks up firm and moist instead of soft and watery.
The best way: overnight in the fridge
Move the fish from the freezer to the fridge the night before you want to cook it. A one to two pound fillet usually takes 12 to 24 hours. Set it on a plate or in a shallow dish to catch any drips, and put it on the bottom shelf so nothing leaks onto other food.
If it’s vacuum sealed, open the bag or cut a slit in it before it goes in the fridge. The FDA recommends this for vacuum-packed fish, because the bacteria that cause botulism can grow without air. Opening the bag takes away that risk.
Once it’s thawed, cook it within a day or two.
In a hurry: cold water
Leave the fish sealed (or put it in a zip bag and press the air out), then sink it in a bowl of cold tap water. Change the water every 30 minutes so it stays cold. A typical fillet thaws in about an hour. Cook it right away.
Don’t use warm or hot water. The outside starts to cook and gets mushy while the middle is still frozen, and warm water is where bacteria grow fastest.
Skip the counter and go easy on the microwave
Leaving fish on the counter puts the outside in the danger zone for hours while the center catches up. The microwave defrost setting works in a pinch, but it tends to cook the thin edges, so cook the fish as soon as it comes out.
You can cook it straight from frozen
Forgot to pull it out? Rinse off any ice glaze, pat it dry and cook it frozen. Plan on about 50 percent more time than a thawed fillet. Roasting or baking works best here:
- Heat the oven to 425°F.
- Brush the frozen fillet with olive oil and set it skin side down on a lined sheet pan.
- Roast about 8 minutes, then season it. Salt sticks better once the surface has thawed.
- Keep roasting until it’s done, usually another 8 to 12 minutes for a one inch thick fillet.
Pan-searing from frozen is harder, since the outside burns before the inside is ready. Save the hot pan for thawed fish.
Cooking thawed king salmon
Pat the fillet very dry with paper towels. Thawed fish carries extra water on the surface, and a wet fillet steams instead of searing. Salt it 10 to 15 minutes before it hits the pan.
From there, cook it like fresh fish. Our guide to cooking fresh salmon walks through the high-heat pan sear we like best, and there are more ideas on our salmon recipes page.
How done is done?
The USDA says to cook fish to 145°F. A lot of cooks pull king salmon earlier, around 120°F to 125°F, for a softer, medium-rare center, then let it rest a few minutes. That’s your call. An instant-read thermometer in the thickest part takes the guessing out of it.
How long does frozen salmon keep?
Well-wrapped or vacuum-sealed salmon holds its best quality for about 3 to 6 months in a home freezer at 0°F. It stays safe longer than that, but the texture and flavor start to slip. If you see dry, white, leathery patches, that’s freezer burn. Trim them off and cook the rest.
Want fresh king salmon next season?
We fish Monterey Bay out of Santa Cruz and sell whole king salmon straight off the boat when the season is open. Get on the list and we’ll let you know when fish are coming in.
